MENTAL HEALTH OF ANIMAL RIGHTS
ACTIVISTS?
James Swan in his book "In Defense of
Hunting" examines the motivations of AR supporters (who BTW tend to be
predominantly white, urban, and female).
He states: "It is possible that some
animal rights activists have taken up their cause because they are
emotionally immature and are acting out repressed rage and hatred from
emotional wounds from parental abuse or from failed love affairs, seeing
the plight of "defenseless animals" as symbolically similar to
how they may feel they have been personally treated by a dominating
human..." [p. 188]
And:
"Vegetarianism can be an act of
spiritual devotion and greater health, and it can also be an early
symptom of guilt-driven suicide." [p.188]
And:
"It is not necessarily an intense love
of animals that prompts individuals to participate in the animal rights
movement. Peter Singer, whose book "Animal Liberation" is seen
as the jumping-off place for the modern animal rights campaign, openly
states that he is not inordinately fond of animals. Wayne Pacelle
[national director Fund for Animals] says he feels the same way..."
[p 116]
And:
"A 1990 Gallup Poll of one thousand
Americans asked the question: "Certain animal rights groups
want a total ban on all types of hunting. Do you support or oppose this
goal?" Of the respondents, 77 percent opposed this goal. The
poll found that 72 percent did have at least some respect for the
positions which animal rights activists take, but 90 percent opposed
hunter harassment. And when asked about their overall attitudes toward
animal rights activists, only 7 percent agreed with what the animal
rights groups are trying to accomplish and approve of how they are going
about it." [p.163] -- James A. Swan. 1995. "In Defense of
Hunting". HarperCollins, New York. ISBN 0-06-251237-4
|